X
(All Fields are required)
Other Resource

Safety Problems at Compounding Pharmacies Confirm Need for Better Oversight


The U.S. Food and Drug Administration late last week said it found widespread safety violations at more than two dozen specialized compounding pharmacies. The agency’s announcement comes after a nationwide outbreak of meningitis that killed more than 50 people and sickened hundreds who received contaminated injections made at a Massachusetts pharmacy.

Related: Summary of the Pharmacy Sterile Compounding Summit (PDF)
Table: U.S. Illnesses and Deaths Associated With Compounded Medications
Video: Briefing on Pharmacy Sterile Compounding Summit Proceedings

These recent events emphasize the need to strengthen oversight of the industry. An analysis by The Pew Charitable Trusts released this year found that 20 compounding errors over the previous decade were associated with 75 deaths and 1,022 illnesses. The call for better oversight was underscored by participants in a recent stakeholder summit convened by Pew, the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists, and the American Hospital Association, which today released the proceedings and recommendations on pharmacy sterile compounding.

The Pharmacy Sterile Compounding Summit included representatives of pharmacy organizations, doctors, hospitals and healthcare systems, compounding pharmacies, the FDA, state pharmacy boards, and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Participants discussed how to address risks related to compounding -- reviewing the scope of the practice, quality standards, and oversight gaps.

Informed by these discussions, Pew, the American Society of Health-System Pharmacists, and the American Hospital Association offer the following recommendations:

  • Federal oversight must be strengthened for activities that go beyond traditional state-regulated pharmacy compounding and represent a high public health risk. Risk factors to be considered include volume of production, breadth of distribution, and inherent risk of the product itself.
  • Federal and state authorities should have clear roles and responsibilities to ensure the safety of compounded sterile drugs without leaving oversight gaps or duplicating efforts.
  • Regulators should consider establishing new quality standards for large-scale sterile compounding.
  • State pharmacy inspectors should have standardized training and assessment tools for consistent and robust oversight.

The deaths attributed to contaminated compounded medicines highlight the risks associated with facilities that no longer function as traditional pharmacies, yet are not regulated as manufacturers. Compounding pharmacies may prepare large batches of drugs and ship them to hospitals, clinics, and doctor’s offices across the United States. Current gaps in oversight of these operations have led to a regulatory limbo for the FDA, which oversees drug manufacturers, and states, which have primary authority over pharmacies in their jurisdiction.  

Date added:
Apr 15, 2013

Related Resources

Pew Comment Letter to the Senate HELP Committee on Compounding Legislation

Issue Brief

Pew sent a comment letter to the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions on the Pharmaceutical Compounding Quality and Accountability Act. This bill takes steps toward clarifying state and federal oversight of compounding, including an important increase in FDA supervision of certain activities—specifically, the compounding of sterile medicines that are shipped interstate.

More

''Lawmaker Would Give FDA More Oversight of Drug Compounding''

Media Coverage

Representative Edward Markey, a Democrat from Massachusetts, on Thursday became the latest lawmaker to propose legislation that would give the U.S. Food and Drug Administration greater regulatory authority over drug compounding.

More

Pew Testimony: Examining Drug Compounding

Issue Brief

On Thursday, May 23, the House Energy & Commerce Subcommittee on Health held a hearing, entitled "Examining Drug Compounding." Gabrielle Cosel, a drug safety expert, testified on the need to clarify oversight of compounding pharmacies on the state and federal level.

 

More

''Senate Panel Approves Tighter Oversight of Compounding Pharmacies, but Bill is Under Fire''

Media Coverage

Public health and consumer advocacy groups are attacking Senate legislation designed to tighten oversight of specialized pharmacies such as the one at the center of this past fall’s deadly meningitis outbreak, saying it does not adequately address health risks.

More

''Rep. Bob Latta's Plan to Thwart Fake Drugs Passes House of Representatives Committee''

Media Coverage
An Ohio legislator’s plan to establish a nationwide prescription drug tracking system to protect patients from fake drugs was approved by the House Commerce Committee. More

''Drug Manufacturer Agrees to $500 Million Penalty''

Media Coverage

''A subsidiary of India's largest pharmaceutical company has agreed to pay a record $500 million in fines and penalties for selling adulterated drugs and lying to federal regulators in a case that is part of an ongoing crackdown on the quality of generic drugs flowing into the U.S."

More

''Community Pharmacies Will Now Back Supply Chain Legislation''

Media Coverage

"As differing bills for securing the pharmaceutical supply chain wind their way through the US House and Senate, a key hurdle to passing legislation may have just been cleared. Earlier this week, the National Community Pharmacists Association – which is a member of an influential industry coalition that has been floating its own proposals – is now willing to back either bill."

More

''Senators Say They Are Close to Writing a Final Pharmacy Compounding Bill''

Media Coverage

"U.S. senators considering fundamental changes to how the practice of pharmacy compounding is regulated heard almost unanimous support for reform at a Washington committee hearing Thursday."

More

''Senate Moves Closer to Law to Prevent More Pharmacy Outbreaks''

Media Coverage

"At least 67 people have died in 20 outbreaks caused by contaminated drugs since 2001, experts told a Senate hearing Thursday. The Food and Drug Administration says there have likely been more cases than that, but they have no way of telling now."

More

''State Pharmacy Boards Back More FDA Oversight''

Media Coverage

"State pharmacy officials on Thursday threw their support behind a proposal giving the Food and Drug Administration authority over large compounding pharmacies, in an effort to head off more outbreaks tied to contaminated medications."

More

Pew Testimony on the Safety of Compounding Pharmacies

Issue Brief

The U.S. Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions held a hearing on May 9 entitled "Pharmaceutical Compounding: Proposed Legislative Solution." Pew's Allan Coukell, a pharmacist and drug safety expert, testified on the need to strengthen oversight of the compounding industry.

More

''The Senate Aims to Clean Up Compounding Pharmacies''

Opinion

When a doctor sticks a needle in you, you expect that the drugs it carries won’t be tainted. But, possibly owing to a strange gray area in federal law, thousands of patients last October got injections for back pain that contained highly dangerous fungal meningitis, and dozens of them died. Members of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee are now seeking to fix the government’s oversight of the obscure world of compounding pharmacies. The reforms they want are overdue.

More

Pew Comments to Senate HELP Committee on Drug Distribution Security

Other Resource

The Pew Charitable Trusts commented on the draft proposal to secure drug distribution in the United States. Although recognizing that the draft is the product of a sustained effort to address a complex system and balance sometimes competing imperatives, Pew shared areas of significant concern.

More

Pew Testimony to House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Health Regarding Drug Supply Chain

Issue Brief

The House Energy & Commerce Subcommittee on Health will hold a hearing on April 25 entitled "Securing Our Nation’s Prescription Drug Supply Chain." Allan Coukell, a pharmacist and drug safety expert, will testify on the need to establish a national system to track and authenticate medicine. The principles outlined in his prepared testimony are supported by other stakeholders in statements from consumer, patient, public health, and industry groups.

More

U.S. Illnesses and Deaths Associated With Compounded Medications

Other Resource

The Pew Charitable Trusts has identified 20 pharmacy compounding errors associated with 1022 adverse events, including 75 deaths, since 2001.

More