.jpg "Interactive: Calculating The Cost: A look into your child's school meal")
''New regulations promote healthier snack foods in schools''
Jessica Donze Black speaks with Online Athens about the USDA's decision to set nutrition standards on school snack foods and beverages.
More info
|
What do the data show in terms of budgets and snack food and beverage policies?
NW: We found that food service revenues and school meal participation increased in states that implemented nutrition policies for snack foods and beverages. The HIA looked at school food service revenue and school meal participation for all 50 states and the District of Columbia from 2003 to 2008. We compared changes in earnings and participation levels for states that adopted these policies during this period both before and after the standards were instated, and compared these changes to states that did not implement a policy. This allowed us to develop a reasonable estimate of the net effect, or the fluctuations in income and participation, that occurred specifically due to snack guidelines.
JDB: This is really important because one of the negative arguments we keep hearing is that strong rules for snack foods and beverages cause districts to lose money. In looking at the data, we learned that is not the case and that after implementing such policies, district budgets stayed the same or even increased. This means that nutrition standards are good for both students’ waistlines and schools’ bottom lines.
Can you walk us through an example of how schools can make the snack food environment healthier without losing money?
NW: The data indicate that when healthier standards are in place, students may spend less on snacks, but they then spend more on meals. And when students buy school meals, the school gets additional reimbursement from the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). This suggests that schools that make the switch to healthy snack food and beverages tend to see any reduction in sales of snacks more than made up for by increased revenue in the school meals program.
JDB: This explains how thousands of schools around the country that have been working to improve the nutrition of the snacks sold were able to do so in a financially sound way. School districts that have had the most success making the foods sold in schools healthier have done so by making kids part of the process. In particular, including students in the selection of healthier snack foods and beverages via surveys, focus groups, and/or taste tests, as well as talking to them about the reasons for changes, can lead to improved student acceptance and consumption of the healthier items.
Can you give us an example of a school district that is doing a good job with making snacks healthier? What was the financial impact of these changes?
JDB: Cincinnati public schools have made tremendous improvements in this area. The School Food Service Director, Jessica Shelly, worked with district administrators and the school board to implement Ohio’s nutrition standards for snack foods and beverages a full year before they were required to do so by the state. Since implementing these guidelines, the district has seen a dramatic increase in school meal participation—64 percent in high schools and 90 percent in elementary schools—which turned a previous budget deficit into a $4.5 million surplus. Because the district drastically improved school meals and made changes to snacks at the same time, students couldn’t turn to less healthy snacks and were driven to try the new and improved lunch program, increasing meal participation to its highest level in two decades. As a result, more students throughout the city are receiving a well-balanced, nutritious lunch.
What other variables did you consider when reviewing the data?
NW: We wanted to make sure that any changes in school food service revenue could be attributed to the implementation of snack food and beverage standards. To do this, we also took in to account the growth in school enrollment; local child poverty and hunger rates,; the proportion of children in elementary, middle, or high school; the ethnic make-up of school children,; and any growth in the number of schools in a state over this time period. Our findings held after we controlled for all of these factors.
With new nutrition standards for school meals currently being implemented, what challenges remain in the school food environment?
JDB: The updates to nutrition standards for school meals mean that kids are now seeing more servings and varieties of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low-fat dairy. That’s great news, but there’s definitely still more to be done. The next step in improving the school food environment is for the U.S. Department of Agriculture to refresh guidelines for all of the other foods sold in schools, such as snack foods and beverages available in school stores, a la carte lines, and vending machines. USDA just proposed updates to these guidelines for the first time in over 30 years. Given that in the same 30 years, childhood obesity rates have nearly tripled, it is critically important that USDA finalize these rules and ensure that all foods available to children are healthy foods.
What action do you want USDA to take?
JDB: We are urging USDA to work efficiently to finalize updated nutrition standards to help schools sell healthier snack foods and beverages in school stores, a la carte lines and vending machines. Additionally, USDA should consider adopting practices – as recommended in the HIA – to assist schools in effectively implementing these changes. This will be a huge step in ensuring that all foods and beverages sold in U.S. schools are healthy.
Resources
- Date added:
- Feb 12, 2013
- Project:
- Kids' Safe and Healthful Foods Project
- Topic:
- School Food
Related Resources
New Standards for School Vending Machines Provide More Than Just Healthy Snacks
While it might take time before we can evaluate the impact of the new standards, which won’t take effect until September 2014, we can look at what we already know to assess them in comparison to the current status quo. The first hint of the new regulation’s potential comes from the Pew Charitable Trusts Kids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project, showing that children and teens gained less weight over three years if they lived in a state with strong policies on school snacks than if they lived in a state without such standards.
More infoPew Commends Sen. Mikulski on Food Safety Funding, Grants for School Kitchen Improvements
The Pew Charitable Trusts applauds Sen. Barbara Mikulski (D-MD) for her efforts to strengthen food safety protections under the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act, and provide grant funding to help school cafeterias across the nation upgrade their equipment to serve healthy, appealing meals to millions of school children. Funding for both programs was included in a larger bill approved by the Senate Appropriations Committee on Thursday.
More info''What the New USDA Rules for Healthier School Snacks Mean for Schools''
Jessica Donze Black, director of the Kids' Safe and Healthful Foods project, discusses the USDA's decision to finalize interim rules for snack foods and beverages sold in schools.
More infoMore Standards Released for School Nutrition
The Obama administration on Thursday released long-awaited nutrition standards for foods that schoolchildren can buy outside the cafeteria, changes that are intended to combat climbing childhood obesity rates.
More info“USDA touts 'Smart snacks' standards”
The U.S. Department of Agriculture has set new nutrition standards for food sold as snacks in schools, giving fruit and vegetable shippers opportunities for vending machines and snack bars. After considering nearly 250,000 comments, the agency on June 27 published the regulation, called “Smart Snacks in Schools,” also known as the “competitive snacks” rule, for junk food that competes with healthier lunch menus.
More info''Minn. School’s Adjust To USDA Lunch Guidelines''
"Minnesota schools are adjusting after the USDA issued new guidelines on the amount of fat and calories contained in snacks made available in lunchrooms. The guidelines are related to the school lunch changes that went into effect last year that cut calories, fat and sodium on kids’ plates. They’ll now include snacks, sides, and everything else in school."
More info“Brownies Bounced From Cafeterias in Healthier Eating Push”
"Children consume as many as half their daily calories in school, where they spend more time than any location except their homes, according to the Pew Charitable Trusts, which underwrites food safety programs. Studies show snacks add 112 calories to the average elementary-school student’s daily diet, and those who live in states with strong snack policies gain less weight over three years than those without regulations."
More info“New USDA snack standards still not strict enough for some Montgomery parents”
Jessica Donze Black, director of the Kids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project, speaks to the Washington Post about the USDA's decision to finalize interim rules for snack foods and beverages sold in schools.
More info''Rules for School Vending Machines, Snacks Unveiled''
Education Week interviews Jessica Donze Black, director of the Kids' Safe and Healthful Foods Project about the USDA's decision to finalize interim rules on snack foods and beverages sold in schools.
More infoKids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project Applauds USDA for Finalizing Snack Standards for Schools
Jessica Donze Black, director of the Kids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project, issued the following statement regarding the interim final rule by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, or USDA, setting nutrition standards for snack foods and beverages sold in U.S. schools.More info
Infographic Urges USDA to Set National Standards for School Snacks
Although some states and districts have created standards for what can be sold as snacks and beverages in schools, the USDA hasn’t updated national guidelines in over 30 years. An infographic recently released by the Kids’ Safe and Healthful Foods Project summarizes research that supports the need for national nutrition standards for snack foods and beverages sold in schools.
More infoSnack Facts:
View this infographic by Pew's Kids' Safe and Healthful Foods Project to learn more facts about school snacks. More info''2 thumbs up for LBI food''
''While some students look down on food served in school cafeterias, Zoe Deakyne, a sixth-grader at Long Beach Island Elementary School, enjoys getting her lunch there.''
More info''Taste test: Parents to get sampling of RCSD cafeteria food''
"New items such as curried chicken with raisins and apples and broccoli alfredo are part of the City School District’s effort to upgrade its school meal offerings, focusing on foods that are fresh, local and healthy, rather than the old school method of quick and easy."
More info
